Best Plush Dog Toys (Jan 2023 Update)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Are you looking for the Best Plush Dog Toys? If so, you’ve come to the right place.

Choosing the Best Plush Dog Toys can be difficult as there are so many considerations, such as AllStar Marketing Group, BARK, goDog, HERO, Holiday Time, MULTIPET INTERNATIONAL, Outward Hound, Walmart, ZippyPaws. We have done a lot of research to find the top 20 Best Plush Dog Toys available.

The average cost is $17.88. Sold comparable range in price from a low of $2.99 to a high of $161.95.

Based on the research we did, we think Douglas Dickens Black Lab Plush Toy is the best overall. Read on for the rest of the great options and our buying guide, where you can find all the information you need to know before making an informed purchase.

20 Best Plush Dog Toys (20 Sellers)

1. Douglas Dickens Black Lab Plush Toy

Product Details:

Specifications:

Weight 80 oz

Reviews:

2. Vibrant Life Cozy Buddy Sock Monkey Dog Toy, Chew Level 3

Product Details:

Specifications:

Package Dimensions 9.88 x 6.06 x 1.85 inches
Recommended Uses For Product indoor, playtime
Indoor/Outdoor Usage Indoor
Unit Count 4.00 Pound

Reviews:

3. Pearhead Dim Sum Dog Toys, 3 Count, White

Product Details:

Specifications:

Reviews:

Un producto hermoso y perfecto para las mascotas de la familiaMariaTC
Perfect toy for dogs that like squeaker toys that are not too big.L Caryl

4. Pearhead Sushi Bento Pet Toys

Product Details:

Specifications:

Reviews:

My dog loves these cute squeakers. They are quality made and durable.Carol311
So adorable and has quickly become my dogs' favorite toy!EagleMama

5. Trustypup Tough 'n Fun Toy, Donut

Product Details:

Specifications:

Units in Package 1
Directions Care Instructions: Surface wash, air dry. For pets only.
Ingredients All New Material: Polyester Fiber.
Warnings For pets only. Contains small parts. Not intended for children. Pets should be supervised when playing within this toy. Immediately remove toy from pet if any part becomes loose or detached. Store out of pet's reach when not in use. Remove all packaging and dispose of properly, or retain in a safe place, as appropriate.

Reviews:

6. Haute Diggity Dog Barkin Bag Dog Toy

Product Details:

Specifications:

Reviews:

SUPER cute!! Smaller than I expected but worth every dime! My sisters dog will absolutely love it!Wade
Love this “Barkin” bag! Adorable and well made. Great color too! Fast shipping. Highly recommend.Christina B.

7. Haute Diggity Dog Lickcroix Barkling Water Pamplemutt Small

Product Details:

Specifications:

Product Dimensions 5 x 3 x 2 inches; 0.81 Ounces
Item Package Dimensions L x W x H 4.8 x 3.4 x 2.3 inches
Item Dimensions LxWxH 5 x 3 x 2 inches
Recommended Uses For Product Dog
Unit Count 1 Count

Reviews:

Super Cute! My daughter will get a kick out of it!MARY

8. Fabdog Floppy Octopus Dog Toy, Large

Product Details:

Specifications:

Reviews:

My dogs love this toy! Very robust / strong. Highly recommended.Kert

9. Worldw Go Dog Furballz, Purple, Small

Product Details:

Specifications:

Craft Sub Type Pet Supplies
Craft Sub Type2 Dogs
Craft Sub Type3 Toys – Chew

Reviews:

My dog loves this toy so much that I purchased three colors as backupMegan H

10. Petco Plush Racoon With Rope Dog Toy, Small

Product Details:

Specifications:

Primary Brand Petco
Length 6 IN

Reviews:

My pup has non stop fun with this toy. She drags it everywhere with her.Shay97236
Cute toys for small dogs small enough to carry aroundjrth
Great toy for the price my dog loves it very much.Bluebit

11. Petco Plush Pizza Dog Toy, Medium

Product Details:

Specifications:

Primary Brand Petco
Length 9 IN

Reviews:

cute and cheap but doesn't last long. my dog destroyed it in a dayStef88
So adorable. Will give for Christmas gift to all my pups!!LoriD123

12. Hartz Hz Squeakerz Dog Toy

Product Details:

Specifications:

Reviews:

13. Bearington Chewie Yorkshire Terrier Stuffed Animal Toy Dog 13”

Product Details:

Specifications:

Age Range 3 to 12 Years
Assembled Product Weight 1 lb
Assembled Product Dimensions (L x W x H) 1.00 x 1.00 x 1.00 Inches

Reviews:

My granddaughter loves this yorkie. Looks like my 11 yr old real yorkie!wandajgip
We bought this as a gift. She loved it. Its well constructed and has nice fur. It is made to sit up and is not floppy.kray257
Looks so precious! Feels so soft toojst3280-pqkbdasv

14. Fabdog Floppy Camel Dog Toy

Product Details:

Specifications:

Reviews:

Exactly what I was looking for. We'll made. Dog loves it!Sharon P.
This toy is durable. My dog is not a chewer but a sucker and he loves this camels humps :0)Aimee B.
if I could change anything the fabric on the feet area could be stronger as my dog chews it into to ge to the squeaker.Judith G.

15. Multipet Birthday Loofa Dog 12in

Product Details:

Specifications:

Reviews:

She wontShe wont even play with itReeci
These loofa toys are always a hit with our dog. The birthday loofa is a cute birthday gift.Elaine

16. Petco Beak-A-Boo Parrot Plush Dog Toy In Various Styles, Small

Product Details:

Specifications:

Primary Brand Petco
Length 7 IN

Reviews:

My little dog had it tore up the first day and stuffing everywhere
Our Goldens move these for some reason they carry them around and use them as pillows when they lay down.Thechadap

17. Happy Trails Interactive Plush Puppy Toy Battery Operated Dog That Walks, Barks & Does Back Flips, Soft & Snuggly Fur

Product Details:

Specifications:

Product Dimensions 4 x 6.5 x 6.5 inches
Country of Origin China
Release date May 20, 2019
Toy figure type Stuffed Toy

Reviews:

A cute puppy. Works fine. Doesnt really bark, more of a yip sound. A bit on the small side. But acceptable.Beverly

18. Petco Plush Sloth Mermaid Dog Toy, Medium

Product Details:

Specifications:

Primary Brand Petco
Length 9 IN

Reviews:

Our goldendoodle puppy 7 months old loves this toy and has played with it for over 3 months nowCabc

19. Petco Prehistoric Fun Dinosaur Plush Dog Toy In Various Styles, Medium

Product Details:

Specifications:

Primary Brand Petco
Length 9 IN

Reviews:

20. Zippypaws Miniz 3-Pack – Hedgehogs

Product Details:

Reviews:

Thank you for helping me replace the hedgehogs that lost their squeakers and their stuffing!Anonymous