10 Best Homemade Cat Toys (2024 Update)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

When looking for the best homemade cat toys, there are a few key points to consider. First, it’s important to choose toys that are safe for your cat. This means that the toys should be made from materials that are non-toxic and free from sharp edges. Second, the toys should be suitable for the size of your cat. Small cats need toys that are designed for their size and larger cats need toys that can accommodate them. Third, it’s important to choose toys that encourage your cat’s natural instinct to hunt and explore. This could include toys that move, have multiple textures, and are filled with catnip. Fourth, it’s important to choose toys that are easy to clean and maintain. This means that the toys should be easy to disassemble and should be made from materials that do not attract dirt and dust. Finally, it’s important to choose toys that are durable and will last a long time. This means that the toys should be made from durable materials that can withstand wear and tear.

When it comes to choosing the best homemade cat toys, considering these five key points can help you make the best decision for your cat. It’s important to choose toys that are safe, suitable for your cat’s size, encourage natural instincts, are easy to clean and maintain, and are durable. Doing so will ensure that your cat is safe, entertained, and happy.

10 Best Homemade Cat Toys

1. Squishy Diy Toy Maker For Kids

The Squishy DIY Toy Maker is an innovative and creative way for kids to make their own unique squishy toys. With the easy to use tools, kids can cut and slice their squishy shapes, and then use the included stencils and color spray to paint and decorate their creation. The intuitive and user-friendly interface is specifically designed with kids in mind and allows them to quickly and easily craft their own squishy.

The Squishy DIY Toy Maker is perfect for children who want to express their creativity and unleash their imaginations. Not only do they get to design and create a one-of-a-kind squishy toy, but they also get to experience the joy of the creative process. From cutting the squishy shapes to painting and decorating, kids can have fun and enjoy the entire process.

The Squishy DIY Toy Maker also provides a safe and secure environment for kids. With no ads and the option for parental controls, parents can be sure that their children are in a safe environment while having fun.

The Squishy DIY Toy Maker is an ideal way for kids to explore their creative side while having fun. They can use the tools to cut and shape their squishy, and then use the stencils and color spray to paint and decorate their masterpiece. With a safe and secure environment and no ads, parents can rest assured that their children are having fun in a secure environment. The Squishy DIY Toy Maker is the perfect way for kids to express their creativity and have fun.

2. Kitchenaid Rrk150wh 5 Qt. Artisan Series – White (Renewed)

This KitchenAid RRK150WH 5 Qt. Artisan Series – White (Renewed) is certified to be in like-new condition, tested and approved by KitchenAid themselves. This product includes original accessories and comes with a 6-month warranty. The mixer has a powerful 325-watt motor and 10 speeds for mixing a variety of ingredients. The 5-quart stainless steel bowl is large enough for multiple batches of mixing. The tilt-back head provides easy access to mixtures. The KitchenAid RRK150WH 5 Qt. Artisan Series also includes a flat beater, dough hook, and wire whip for various mixing needs. This product measures 14 by 8-2/3 inches by 14 inches, making it the perfect size to fit on any kitchen counter. With its powerful motor, 10 speeds, and generous bowl size, the KitchenAid RRK150WH 5 Qt. Artisan Series is the perfect tool for any baking or cooking project.

3. Catnip Plush Refillable Cat Toy – Random Color

SmartyKat’s Madcap Mania Refillable Plush Catnip Cat Toy is designed to entice cats of all ages. This lightweight and perfectly sized toy encourages cats to pick it up, carry, and play with it. It is filled with a pouch that makes it easy to replenish the catnip and comes with a catnip-filled tube as well.

The catnip contains aromatic oils that give cats a euphoric buzz and stimulates their instincts. Most cats respond to the catnip with a burst of energy, or frenzied behavior, followed by a period of blissful relaxation. The toy is designed with soft plush, felt, jute, and whiskers that simulate the multitextured look and feel of real prey to help stimulate your kitty's hunting instincts and entice play.

The Madcap Mania is perfect for hide-and-seek games with your cat, which ignites their hunting instincts and provides them with much-needed mental stimulation and enrichment. It is also great for engaging independent felines in solo play. To use, lightly squeeze the catnip-filled or compressed items to help release the natural active ingredient in catnip, and spark another round of exciting and frenzied romp and play.

SmartyKat products help pet owners meet basic feline needs. The Madcap Mania Refillable Plush Catnip Cat Toy is the perfect size of 5.75" x 3" x 1" and comes in a randomly selected color. It is an ideal way to foster a stronger connection between cats and their owners.

4. Interactive Cat Toy With North American Catnip – Hot Stuff Chili

OurPets Cosmic Catnip Cat Toy-Hot Stuff is sure to bring hours of joy to your feline friend. Made of 100% North-American-grown Cosmic Catnip, this interactive cat toy helps to stimulate your cat mentally and physically. When pinched, the aromatic catnip stored in the dried leaves is released, driving cats wild!

The OurPets Cosmic Catnip Cat Toy encourages physical play and mental stimulation by appealing to your cat’s natural instincts. This is essential in keeping cats mentally stimulated, which is important in avoiding boredom and fulfilling their hunting instincts. It also relieves stress, anxiety, and boredom, and acts as a workout for cats, keeping them physically fit.

This chili-shaped toy comes in seven different styles for your cat to choose from. The Carrot, Banana, Fish, Snake, Cigar, Cactus & Chili are all 100% filled with North-American-grown Cosmic Catnip to satisfy your kitty's need to play!

Treat your cat to hours of fun with OurPets Cosmic Catnip Cat Toy-Hot Stuff. This interactive cat toy will help to keep your cat both mentally and physically stimulated and aid in relieving stress and anxiety. The seven different styles of catnip toys are sure to keep your kitty entertained!

5. Handmade Felted Wool Mouse Toys (3-Pack) For Indoor Cats And Kittens

Earthtone Solutions is proud to present their Cat Mouse Toy – a unique product handmade by artisan women of Nepal. This sturdy felt wool cat toy set of three mice is sure to bring hours of playtime fun to any indoor cat or kitten. Each mouse measures approximately six inches long and comes in either natural gray, black, or brown.

These adorable hand felted cat mouse toys are designed to provide cats with silent fun. No noisy rattles, bells, or squeaks are included, so you can rest assured that your cat can play without disturbing your peace. The quality of the felted wool cat toys is second to none, with a tight and durable weave that doesn’t require the use of catnip.

Earthtone Solutions is a family-owned American company, trademarked and dedicated to providing cats and their owners with the best quality toys. If you’re looking for an entertaining way to keep your cat active and engaged, this Cat Mouse Toy set is the perfect solution. It’s sure to bring smiles and laughter to your home, and is sure to make your cat purr.

The Cat Mouse Toy is an ideal gift for any cat or kitten, and it offers a unique way to show your pet just how much you care. The perfect combination of quality, playfulness, and natural colors, this product is sure to keep cats entertained for hours. The perfect addition to any cat’s toy collection, this Cat Mouse Toy set is sure to bring joy and laughter to your home.

6. Homedics Soundspa Lullaby: 6 Sounds & Lullabies, Image Projector, Auto-Off Timer, Ac Adapter.

The MyBaby SoundSpa Lullaby from HoMedics is the perfect way to help your baby relax. It plays a variety of six soothing sounds and lullabies, including Heartbeat, Gentle Rain, Ocean Waves, Twinkle, Twinkle, Rock-A-Bye Baby and Cradle Song. The adjustable volume allows you to customize the sound to your baby's preference. It also features an image projector with three diverse scenes, so you can project calming patterns on the wall or ceiling. To help conserve energy, the projector has an auto-off timer, which can be set for 15, 30, 45, or 60 minutes.

The MyBaby SoundSpa Lullaby is made out of durable plastic and is small and compact, making it perfect for travel. It packs easily in any luggage, so your baby can relax wherever you go. It is powered by an AC adapter, and comes with a quick-start guide, as well as an image disc with three scenes.

The MyBaby SoundSpa Lullaby is the ideal product for helping your baby relax and fall asleep. With its soothing sounds and calming images, it is sure to be a hit at naptime. The adjustable volume, auto-off timer and portability make it the perfect sleep aid for babies of all ages.

7. Cat Toys Bath Bombs Set (Usa-Made) – Surprise Inside – Natural & Safe For Kids.

This Bath Bombs Set for Kids with Cat Toys Inside is the perfect gift for any occasion. Kids will love the surprise of finding a cute cat toy inside each colorful fizzy bath ball. The six unique scents, including lavender, monkey farts, candy crush, cocoa kiss, bubble gum, and cotton candy, will make bath time a fun and enjoyable experience.

The organic and natural ingredients used to make these bath bombs are totally harmless and won’t cause any allergic reactions. The bombs will float and fizz in the water, giving it a vibrant color. This set is handmade in the USA and is safe and gentle on the skin.

These bath bombs make bath time a treasured moment for parents and children alike. With these bath bombs, parents can finally have peace of mind knowing that the bombs are free of oils, meaning no oily ring around the tub. Parents can rest assured that their children are enjoying a safe, natural and fun bath time experience.

The perfect choice for a birthday gift, Christmas, Hanukkah, Eid, Easter, Party Favors, or Holiday gifts for boys and girls, toddlers, and tweens. Make bath time a fun and exciting experience for your children and let them have bubbly, fizzy fun with this wonderful bath bomb set.

8. Catnip Donut Toys (4in) – 6 Pack

This 6 Pack Donut Cat Catnip Toys set is a budget-friendly and fun way to get your cats playing. This set includes six interactive and colorful donut-shaped pillows, made of soft and durable flannelette. They are embroidered with sprinkles or colored cream to provide a realistic texture.

The donut toys are 4 inches in diameter, which makes them the perfect size for most kittens. They are also great for adult cats, as they can be used for batting, chasing, chewing, playing, ripping, hiding, scratching, and sleeping.

These donut pillows are filled with pure catnip, an addictive substance that cats love. The catnip can help with digestion, stress relief, and emotional regulation for cats. It can also encourage them to interact with you more, providing hours of entertainment.

These donut-shaped catnip toys make the perfect gift for a cat’s birthday, or for cat photo shoots. They are also great as a decorative piece in any room. If you have any questions or advice, please feel free to contact us. We guarantee satisfaction with every purchase.

9. Kittybelles Klaw Cat Toy With Catnip – Fun & Durable Huxley & Kent

The Kittybelles Kitty Klaw is a fun, durable and safe cat toy that is sure to bring hours of entertainment to your kitty! This plush toy is made of ultra-soft baby plush material that cats will love to snuggle up to and play with. It is filled with powerful catnip and a crinkle for extra exciting play time.

Cats have natural predatory instincts and need an outlet to express this behavior in a safe and healthy way. This plush toy provides an outlet to do so and helps to relieve boredom, as well as anxiety. It is made with top-of-the-line materials to ensure the well-being of your pet.

The realistic-looking plush toy makes a great gift for the feline enthusiast in your life. They will appreciate the fun and whimsical design, and their cat will love the stimulating play. With the Kittybelles Kitty Klaw, cats can bat it around, pounce on it, and rub the plush for hours of entertainment. It is sure to become one of your cat's favorite toys!

10. Barn Yarn Hand Knit Wool Cat Toy With Catnip 6 Pack

This Barn Yarn Hand Knit Wool Cat Toy with Catnip 6 Pack is the perfect way for your kitty to have hours of fun! These toys are meticulously hand-knit from 100% wool, and each one is filled with catnip for extra appeal. The pack includes 6 toys, each in a unique shape or design, so your cat won’t get bored. Whether they come in the shape of animals or characters, your feline friend will love the variety of toys. Cats love the soft texture of wool, which makes it a great material for cat toys. Plus, the catnip inside is sure to get your kitty’s attention. Not only is this cat toy visually appealing, but it’s also safe and eco-friendly. This 6 pack of Barn Yarn Hand Knit Wool Cat Toys with Catnip is the perfect way to give your cat the variety they need to stay entertained.

Best Homemade Cat Toys FAQs

How do you make homemade cat toys?

Making homemade cat toys is a great way to keep your cat entertained and provide them with some mental stimulation. Here are some ideas for DIY cat toys:

1. Catnip Mice: Take a small piece of felt and cut it into a mouse shape. Fill it with catnip and sew it shut. You can also add a bell or some crinkle paper inside for extra fun.

2. Feather Wand: Take a stick or dowel and attach some feathers or other lightweight material to the end. This is a great way to get your cat to exercise and have fun.

3. Cardboard Boxes: Cats love to explore and hide in boxes. Cut some holes in a cardboard box and let your cat explore. You can also add some toys or treats inside for extra fun.

4. Paper Bag: Take a paper bag and cut some holes in it. Put some treats or toys inside and let your cat explore.

5. DIY Cat Tree: Take some wood and build a cat tree. You can add some scratching posts, platforms, and toys to make it even more fun.

These are just a few ideas for homemade cat toys. With a little creativity, you can make your own unique toys that your cat will love. Just make sure to use safe materials and supervise your cat while they play.

What household items can cats play with?

Cats are playful creatures and can have a lot of fun with a variety of household items. Some of the most popular items for cats to play with include cardboard boxes, paper bags, paper towel rolls, and empty plastic bottles. Cardboard boxes provide cats with a safe and enclosed space to explore and hide in, while paper bags and paper towel rolls can be used as makeshift tunnels and scratching posts. Empty plastic bottles can be filled with treats or catnip and rolled around for cats to chase and bat at. Additionally, cats can enjoy playing with feather toys, laser pointers, and interactive toys such as puzzle feeders. These toys can help keep cats mentally and physically stimulated, and can help prevent boredom and destructive behavior. Finally, cats can also enjoy playing with catnip-filled toys, which can help to encourage play and provide cats with a sense of comfort and security.

What materials are safe for cat toys?

When it comes to cat toys, safety should always be the top priority. The best materials for cat toys are those that are non-toxic, durable, and easy to clean. Natural materials such as sisal rope, jute, and cotton are all safe for cats to play with. Plush toys made from polyester or cotton are also safe, as long as they are free of any small parts that could be swallowed. Avoid toys made from plastic, as they can contain toxins that can be harmful to cats.

Catnip is a great way to keep cats entertained, but it should be used in moderation. Catnip toys should be made from natural materials such as cotton or jute, and should be free of any small parts that could be swallowed.

When it comes to balls and other small toys, make sure they are large enough that they cannot be swallowed. Avoid any toys with small parts that could be swallowed, such as bells or buttons.

Finally, always supervise your cat when they are playing with toys. This will help ensure that they are playing safely and not ingesting any small parts. If you notice any signs of distress or discomfort, remove the toy immediately and consult your veterinarian.

What toy do cats like the most?

Cats are known for their playful nature and love of toys. The type of toy that cats like the most will depend on the individual cat, but there are some toys that are generally popular among cats. Catnip toys are a great option, as cats are naturally attracted to the scent of catnip. Catnip toys come in a variety of shapes and sizes, and can provide hours of entertainment for cats. Laser pointers are also a great option, as cats love to chase the light. Interactive toys, such as feather wands and wand toys, are also popular among cats. These toys allow cats to engage in a game of chase and can provide mental stimulation. Additionally, cats love to play with balls, crinkle toys, and stuffed animals.

No matter what type of toy you choose for your cat, it is important to make sure that it is safe and non-toxic. Additionally, it is important to monitor your cat’s playtime and make sure that they are not ingesting any pieces of the toy. Finally, it is important to provide your cat with a variety of toys to keep them entertained and engaged. With the right toys, cats can have hours of fun and mental stimulation.