10 Best Cat Treats For Picky Cats (2024 Update)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

When it comes to cats, there is no one-size-fits-all approach when it comes to food. Some cats are picky eaters, while others will eat anything you put in front of them. Finding the best cat treats for picky cats can be a challenge, but it doesn't have to be. Here are five key points to consider when looking for the best cat treats for your picky feline:

1. Natural ingredients: Look for cat treats that are made with natural ingredients, such as real meat, fish, or vegetables. Avoid treats with artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives.

2. Flavor and texture: Picky cats may be more likely to try a treat if it has an appealing flavor and texture. Look for treats that have a variety of flavors and textures, such as crunchy, chewy, and soft.

3. Nutritional value: Make sure the treats you choose are nutritionally balanced. Look for treats that are high in protein, low in fat, and contain other essential nutrients.

4. Allergens: If your cat has any known allergies, make sure to avoid treats containing those ingredients.

5. Price: Look for treats that are within your budget. Don't be afraid to buy in bulk or try out different brands to find the best value.

With these five key points in mind, you can find the best cat treats for your picky cat. Whether you're looking for crunchy treats, soft treats, or a variety of flavors, there are plenty of options to choose from. With a little bit of research and some trial and error, you can find the perfect treats for your feline friend.

10 Best Cat Treats For Picky Cats

1. Rachael Ray Nutrish Cat Treats Variety Pack, 2.2 Ounces (Pack Of 8)

Introducing the Rachael Ray Nutrish Cat Treats Variety Pack, an assortment of delectable snacks for your kitty! This 8-pack contains two bags of Salmon Love Bites cat treats with crunchy shells and tender centers, two bags of Chicken Love Bites cat treats with crunchy shells and tender centers, two bags of Wheelies crunchy and smooth swirled cat treats with chicken, and two bags of Soft Spots soft and savory cat treats with salmon.

Your cat will love snacking on these delicious treats, made with natural ingredients and no artificial flavors or preservatives. The Salmon Love Bites are made with real salmon to provide a tasty, crunchy snack with a tender center. The Chicken Love Bites feature real chicken and a crunchy shell with a tender center. The Wheelies are perfect for cats who love a crunchy and smooth texture, made with real chicken and a swirl of crunchy and smooth flavors. The Soft Spots are made with real salmon, providing a soft and savory treat that your cat will love.

These treats are sure to please your furry friend, providing a delicious snack that’s both healthy and delicious. With natural ingredients and no artificial flavors or preservatives, you can be sure your cat is getting the best. The variety pack ensures there’s something for every cat, and with eight bags of treats you’ll have enough to last for a while.

Treat your cat to the Rachael Ray Nutrish Cat Treats Variety Pack and give them the deliciousness they deserve. With a variety of flavors and textures, they’re sure to have a snack they love. So give your cat a delicious treat and watch them purr with pleasure.

2. Grain-Free Tuna Variety Cat Treats, 0.5oz, 20 Tubes, Vitamin E & Taurine.

INABA Churu Cat Treats are a grain-free, lickable and squeezable purée cat treat/topper with added Vitamin E and Taurine. Every Inaba product is made with human-grade ingredients to provide your feline friend with a delicious and healthy snack. These creamy purée tubes contain 91% moisture and only 6 calories, making them a low-calorie treat you can feel good about giving your cat.

Inaba Churu Cat Treats are free of grains, preservatives, artificial colors and carrageenan, so you can trust that your cat is getting only the best. These treats were designed to be fed by hand, as an interactive way to spend time with your cat, but you can also use them as a wet/dry cat food topper or as a way to disguise medication. Your cat will love the eleven savory flavors available, as cats of all ages will be able to find something they love.

INABA Churu Cat Treats are a great way to show your cat some love in a healthy and delicious way. As a grain-free, lickable and squeezable purée, your cat will love the taste and texture. With only 6 calories per tube and added Vitamin E and Taurine, you can trust that your cat is getting the best in nutrition and hydration without adding a lot of calories. With eleven savory flavors, your cat will never get bored with the variety of flavors. Whether you feed it by hand as an interactive way to spend time with your cat, or use it as a wet/dry cat food topper or to disguise medication, INABA Churu Cat Treats are an ideal way to show your cat some love.

3. Blue Buffalo Bursts Crunchy Cat Treats, Seafood 5-Oz Bag

BLUE Bursts Crunchy Cat Treats, Seafood is the perfect treat for your feline friend. This bag of crunchy cat treats offers your cat a unique texture combination – a crunchy shell and a delicious creamy center that cats can’t resist. It all starts with real fish, which is the first ingredient in this healthy treat. You can feel good about giving your cat BLUE Bursts because they contain only wholesome ingredients. There are no poultry by-product meals, no corn, wheat or soy, and no artificial flavors or preservatives.

BLUE Bursts Crunchy Cat Treats, Seafood are the perfect way to show your cat how much you care about their health and happiness. Not only do they taste great, but they are also packed with the healthy, wholesome ingredients you want your cat to enjoy. Your cat will love the two tempting textures these treats offer. The crunchy shell and creamy center are sure to please even the pickiest of cats.

A bag of BLUE Bursts Crunchy Cat Treats, Seafood is the perfect way to show your cat some love. These treats are made with the highest quality ingredients and provide great taste with every bite. Your cat is sure to love the delicious flavor combination and you can feel good knowing that the treats are healthy and wholesome. With no artificial flavors or preservatives, you can trust that these treats are the best for your feline friend.

4. Herbsmith Freeze-Dried Salmon Cat Food Topper

Herbsmith Sassy Cat Kibble Seasoning is a freeze-dried salmon cat food topper that is perfect for picky eaters. The salmon used in this product is wild-caught and responsibly sourced in the USA. This cat food seasoning contains zero additives, fillers, flavors, dyes, preservatives, or grains, making it a great choice for cats with allergies. It is also 100% free of corn, wheat, and soy.

The freeze-drying process of this cat food topper allows for a flavor-packed mix of delicious and nutritious meals. The freeze-dried salmon retains nearly 100% of its whole food vitamins and minerals because it’s processed at such low temperatures. As pet parents, you don’t have to worry about deciphering long ingredient decks with obscure names. Herbsmith Sassy Cat Kibble Seasoning contains a single ingredient: wild-caught salmon.

Created by holistic veterinarian, Dr. Chris Bessent, this product is of the highest quality you can trust. It has also been rated #1 by picky eaters! No matter your cat’s pallet, there’s a flavor for every one. Not only is this cat food topper delicious, but it’s also healthy. Herbsmith Sassy Cat Kibble Seasoning contains only fresh, high-quality ingredients that are good for your cat. Feed them something they will love and you can trust. Try Herbsmith Sassy Cat Kibble Seasoning today!

5. Amazon Egift Card – Happy Birthday – Funny Frog (Animated)

This Amazon eGift Card – Happy Birthday – Funny Frog (Animated) makes the perfect gift for any occasion. With multiple gift card designs and denominations to choose from, you can select the perfect gift for any budget. Redeemable towards millions of items store-wide at Amazon.com or certain affiliated websites, this gift card is available for immediate delivery.

Gift cards sent by email can be scheduled up to a year in advance, and never expire or carry any fees. With no returns or refunds on Gift Cards, you can be sure that your recipient will be able to select the perfect gift for themselves. The Amazon.com Gift Cards can only be used to purchase eligible goods and services on Amazon.com and certain related sites, as provided in the Amazon.com Gift Card Terms and Conditions.

If you need to purchase a gift card for use on an Amazon website in another country, please visit Amazon.ca, Amazon.cn, Amazon.fr, Amazon.de, Amazon.in, Amazon.it, Amazon.co.jp, Amazon.co.uk, Amazon.es, or Amazon.com.au. This Amazon eGift Card – Happy Birthday – Funny Frog (Animated) makes the perfect gift for any occasion, offering the recipient the freedom to select their own perfect gift.

6. Grain-Free Tuna Cat Treats, Squeezable Purée With Vitamin E & Taurine, 0.5oz/60 Tubes.

The INABA Churu Cat Treats are the perfect way to give your cat a delicious and healthy snack. These grain-free, lickable, squeezable creamy purée treats are made with wholesome ingredients, so you can trust that they are healthy and good for your cat. Each treat contains 91% moisture and only 6 calories, making them an excellent low-calorie snack. Plus, they are free of grains, preservatives, artificial colors, and carrageenan, but contain Taurine to help with your cat’s overall health.

These treats are designed to be fed by hand as an interactive way to spend time with your feline, or as a wet or dry cat food topper. With nineteen savory flavors to choose from, cats of all ages and stages will be able to find one that they love. You can trust that these treats are a healthy, low-calorie snack for your cat that you can feel good about giving them.

Give your cat the delicious snack they deserve with INABA Churu Cat Treats. These treats are made with wholesome ingredients you can trust, and are free of grains, preservatives, artificial colors, and carrageenan. They contain 91% moisture and only 6 calories, making them a low-calorie snack, and they are also packed with Taurine to help with your cat’s overall health. With nineteen savory flavors, you can give your cat a different treat every day of the week. Feed them by hand for an interactive way to spend time with your feline, or use as a wet or dry cat food topper. Get your cat the tasty and healthy snack they deserve with INABA Churu Cat Treats.

Best Cat Treats For Picky Cats FAQs

What can you give a picky cat?

Picky cats can be difficult to please, but there are a few things you can do to make sure your cat is happy and healthy.

First, make sure your cat has access to fresh, clean water at all times. Cats can be picky about their water, so try offering a variety of bowls and water sources to see what your cat prefers.

Second, provide your cat with a variety of high-quality wet and dry food. Cats can be picky eaters, so it’s important to offer a variety of flavors and textures. You can also try adding a few drops of tuna juice or chicken broth to the food to make it more appealing.

Third, make sure your cat has plenty of toys and activities to keep them entertained. Cats can get bored easily, so it’s important to provide them with a variety of toys and activities to keep them engaged. Try offering a variety of scratching posts, catnip toys, and interactive toys to keep your cat entertained.

Finally, make sure your cat has plenty of places to hide and relax. Cats need a safe place to retreat to when they’re feeling stressed or overwhelmed. Provide your cat with a variety of hiding spots, such as cat trees, cat beds, and cardboard boxes.

By following these tips, you can ensure that your picky cat is happy and healthy.

What to give a cat who doesn't like treats?

If your cat doesn't like treats, there are still plenty of ways to show them love and appreciation. One of the best ways to do this is to provide them with plenty of interactive playtime. Cats are naturally curious and love to explore, so providing them with toys that they can chase and bat around can be a great way to keep them entertained and engaged. You can also try providing them with a scratching post or other scratching surfaces to help keep their claws healthy and their minds stimulated.

Another way to show your cat love is to provide them with a comfortable place to sleep. Cats love to curl up in a warm, cozy spot, so providing them with a soft bed or blanket can be a great way to show them that you care. Additionally, you can provide them with a variety of different textures and materials to explore, such as a cardboard box or a paper bag.

Finally, you can also provide your cat with a variety of different scents and aromas to explore. Cats have a very keen sense of smell, so providing them with different scents to explore can be a great way to keep them engaged and entertained. You can try using essential oils, catnip, or even just a few drops of your favorite perfume.

Overall, there are plenty of ways to show your cat love and appreciation, even if they don't like treats. Providing them with interactive playtime, a comfortable place to sleep, and a variety of different scents and aromas to explore can all be great ways to show your cat that you care.

What treats do cats like the most?

Cats are known for their finicky nature, but there are a few treats that they tend to enjoy. The most popular treats for cats are wet food, such as canned tuna or salmon, as well as small pieces of cooked chicken or turkey. Cats also enjoy treats made specifically for them, such as freeze-dried liver, freeze-dried shrimp, and catnip. Treats made with fish oil, such as salmon oil, are also popular with cats.

Cats also enjoy treats that are high in protein, such as freeze-dried chicken, freeze-dried beef, and freeze-dried liver. Treats made with natural ingredients, such as freeze-dried fruits and vegetables, are also popular with cats. Treats made with probiotics, such as yogurt, are also popular with cats.

Cats also enjoy treats that are high in fiber, such as freeze-dried pumpkin, freeze-dried sweet potato, and freeze-dried peas. Treats made with natural ingredients, such as freeze-dried fruits and vegetables, are also popular with cats. Treats made with probiotics, such as yogurt, are also popular with cats.

Cats also enjoy treats that are high in fat, such as freeze-dried salmon, freeze-dried mackerel, and freeze-dried sardines. Treats made with natural ingredients, such as freeze-dried fruits and vegetables, are also popular with cats. Treats made with probiotics, such as yogurt, are also popular with cats.

Overall, cats enjoy a variety of treats, but the most popular treats are those that are high in protein, fiber, and fat. Treats made with natural ingredients, such as freeze-dried fruits and vegetables, are also popular with cats. Treats made with probiotics, such as yogurt, are also popular with cats.